By Amy Webb, Ph.D.
You know those cheesy sitcoms from the early days of TV? You’ve probably seen clips of those black and white shows that show the idealized family from the 1950s and 60s. You know the ones like Leave it to Beaver? One thing that you’ll notice in these shows is the lack of time parents actually spend interacting with their kids. Sure, they eat dinner together but you don’t see parents playing games with their kids or organizing playdates.
While these shows are fiction, there is a bit of reality in this too. Studies show that parents today spend way more time engaged actively with their kids (not just fixing their meals or taking them to school) than ever before. That’s right. You probably spend more “quality” time interacting with your kids that your parents did.
Why Play Matters for Emotions
While there are many benefits to this, there can be some drawbacks too. While spending more time playing with kids can be helpful to them, too much intrusion while they are playing can inhibit their natural learning and growth. A recent study from Stanford University illustrates this well.
The study looked at 4-6-year-olds and considered how their parents interacted with them while playing. The study found that some parents tended to step in to give directions, ask questions, or offer corrections even when the children were on task and doing what they were asked to do. Among children of these parents, they had more difficulty regulating emotions and behavior at other times in the study.
This shows a link between parents’ over-involvement in play and kids’ self-regulation skills. While we don’t want to jump to too many conclusions based on one study, it does provide support for the idea that too much interference in playtime can stifle kids' emerging self-regulation skills. In other words, when kids are allowed to take the lead in play, they build self-regulation and independence skills more easily.
Finding the Balance
This is great news for parents! It means we don’t have to feel guilty about taking a break and letting our kids play on their own. But how do we find that fine balance between guiding and supporting their play while not interfering?
A few tips for finding playtime perfection:
Follow your child’s lead (when possible). If your child has an idea for a playtime activity, try to go along with their plan (as long as it’s safe, of course!). Allow them the time and space to figure out what game to play or which pretend character to be.
Observe first. If you feel the need to intervene in your children’s play, take a moment to observe what they are doing first. Are they off-task or not understanding the rules? Think about how you might intervene to keep them engaged in play without completely taking over the situation. Think of yourself more as a coach rather than a teammate.
Different isn’t wrong. Children often play or do activities differently than we would have done them. It’s tempting to take over the activity and do it “our way.” Consider for a moment, however, if the child’s approach to the activity is wrong or just different. If it is safe and they seem to be enjoying the activity, maybe it’s okay to allow them to do it a different way. Just think of all the creativity they are developing!
Play is powerful in the early years of children’s development. By allowing them to take the lead, you are helping playtime turn into learning time.
Amy Webb, Ph.D. is a mom of two and a child development writer at her blog The Thoughtful Parent. She is passionate about bringing child development research into the lives of parents so they can use it to inform their parenting decisions.
Like this post? Don't forget to sign up for our free text messages,
with info timed exactly to your child's birthdate.
Text BRIGHT to 274 448 to sign up.